Jim Schutze fisks my D Magazine pals for their special issue on the Trinity project.
Tim Rogers responds.
I'm of mixed hearts and minds on this one. I haven't read all of the backup material Schutze cites; nor, frankly, the entire Trinity special, which was very, very loooong.
When we talk about having reporters bring voice into every story, that will inevitably lead to a certain amount of issue-advocacy.
Using a major (at least locally) media outlet to advocate a civic or mass-commercial cause is a tricky thing. I should know: While it would be a stretch to say that I was the father of these sorts of specials that D does periodically, I at least bought drinks and played wingman on the night she was conceived. And I've taken the old gal out on a couple dates -- once during the early days of the Dallas 2012 Olympic Bid campaign; and later in service of a group called "Decade of Progress" that was trying to pass a bond referendum benefitting a lots of arts organizations (and, by the way also a new NBA stadium) in Charlotte.
But, I'll have to admit, she doesn't look quite the same to me as she did back in the day. Is she fish or fowl? Journalism or propaganda? Or both? And how does this turducken fly in a Journalism 2.0 environment?
D certainly isn't alone in doing advocacy specials.
I'm interested to hear what other Pegasi think.
Whatever you think of Schutze's take on the Trinity, the column (ostensibly a year-ender) begins with a beaut of a lede (best appreciated if you're a Dallasite):
Wow. What a year. The city's ship of state is pulling apart at the
welds. Down in the engine room they're up to their necks in saltwater.
Somebody threw the captain overboard. A big pirate ship from the Park
Cities just hove into view. They want us to behead the remaining
officers. We're thinking about it.
Speaking as a Dallas Observer columnist, this has been the second-best year of my life. The next one will be the best.
Please understand. Rascality and mayhem are to me what wheat is to a miller. And I see bumper crops ahead.
He's right about that. This will be a pivotal year for Our City. Another reason we're in a hurry to get there and cover it.
Recent Comments
ABC screwed the pooch